{
  "slug": "five-substitutions-era",
  "added": "2026-11-06",
  "source": {
    "goal_times": "data_layer/epl_goal_times_2002_2027.json (ESPN public scoreboard, pulled 2026-10-05)",
    "added_time": "data_layer/epl_added_time_2016_2027.json (ESPN match summaries, pulled 2026-10-05)",
    "last_match": "2026-09-20"
  },
  "definitions": "* sample: every Premier League match from 2016-17 (the first season with half lengths in the archive) to\n    20 September 2026 whose goal list adds up to the score (details_ok): 3,848 of 3,850.\n  * the rule periods in the Premier League:\n      - 3 subs: 2016-17 to 2018-19 and 2019-20 up to the March 2020 shutdown;\n      - Project Restart (5 subs in three windows): the 92 matches from 17 June 2020;\n      - 3 subs again: 2020-21 and 2021-22 (the league went back to three);\n      - 5 subs, old added time: 2022-23 (five subs made permanent);\n      - 5 subs + new added time: 2023-24 to 2025-26 (referees add the time actually lost);\n      - 2026-27 to 20 September 2026 reported on its own (50 matches, partial).\n  * \"after 75'\" = a goal ESPN shows at 76' or later, including 90'+N' (ESPN's minute 76 covers 75:00-76:00);\n    split into regulation 76'-90' (no added part) and second-half added time (90'+N', N >= 1). First-half\n    added time (45'+N') counts as before 75'.\n  * second-half length = the added minute in which ESPN's summary shows the half ending (90'+7' -> 7);\n    one 2018-19 match (id 513729) has no end time and is left out of that average only.\n  * added-time goals per added minute = second-half added-time goals / summed end minutes, same matches.\n  * differences between periods carry a normal-approximation 95% interval (two proportions for shares,\n    two Poisson counts for per-match rates).",
  "periods": {
    "A": {
      "matches": 1426,
      "goals": 3932,
      "goals_per_match": 2.76,
      "after_75": 896,
      "after_75_share": 22.8,
      "reg_76_90": 668,
      "reg_76_90_share": 17.0,
      "reg_76_90_per_match": 0.468,
      "added_time_goals": 228,
      "added_time_share": 5.8,
      "added_time_per_match": 0.16,
      "matches_with_end": 1425,
      "mean_end_minute": 5.2,
      "end_minute_sum": 7375,
      "added_time_goals_in_end_matches": 228,
      "added_time_goals_per_added_minute": 0.0309,
      "label": "3 subs: 2016-17 to March 2020",
      "subs": "3",
      "added_time": "old"
    },
    "B": {
      "matches": 92,
      "goals": 250,
      "goals_per_match": 2.72,
      "after_75": 56,
      "after_75_share": 22.4,
      "reg_76_90": 44,
      "reg_76_90_share": 17.6,
      "reg_76_90_per_match": 0.478,
      "added_time_goals": 12,
      "added_time_share": 4.8,
      "added_time_per_match": 0.13,
      "matches_with_end": 92,
      "mean_end_minute": 5.8,
      "end_minute_sum": 535,
      "added_time_goals_in_end_matches": 12,
      "added_time_goals_per_added_minute": 0.0224,
      "label": "Project Restart, June-July 2020",
      "subs": "5",
      "added_time": "old"
    },
    "C": {
      "matches": 760,
      "goals": 2095,
      "goals_per_match": 2.76,
      "after_75": 459,
      "after_75_share": 21.9,
      "reg_76_90": 337,
      "reg_76_90_share": 16.1,
      "reg_76_90_per_match": 0.443,
      "added_time_goals": 122,
      "added_time_share": 5.8,
      "added_time_per_match": 0.161,
      "matches_with_end": 760,
      "mean_end_minute": 5.2,
      "end_minute_sum": 3971,
      "added_time_goals_in_end_matches": 122,
      "added_time_goals_per_added_minute": 0.0307,
      "label": "3 subs again: 2020-21 and 2021-22",
      "subs": "3",
      "added_time": "old"
    },
    "D": {
      "matches": 380,
      "goals": 1084,
      "goals_per_match": 2.85,
      "after_75": 217,
      "after_75_share": 20.0,
      "reg_76_90": 168,
      "reg_76_90_share": 15.5,
      "reg_76_90_per_match": 0.442,
      "added_time_goals": 49,
      "added_time_share": 4.5,
      "added_time_per_match": 0.129,
      "matches_with_end": 380,
      "mean_end_minute": 6.1,
      "end_minute_sum": 2324,
      "added_time_goals_in_end_matches": 49,
      "added_time_goals_per_added_minute": 0.0211,
      "label": "5 subs, old added time: 2022-23",
      "subs": "5",
      "added_time": "old"
    },
    "E": {
      "matches": 1140,
      "goals": 3406,
      "goals_per_match": 2.99,
      "after_75": 829,
      "after_75_share": 24.3,
      "reg_76_90": 542,
      "reg_76_90_share": 15.9,
      "reg_76_90_per_match": 0.475,
      "added_time_goals": 287,
      "added_time_share": 8.4,
      "added_time_per_match": 0.252,
      "matches_with_end": 1140,
      "mean_end_minute": 7.6,
      "end_minute_sum": 8634,
      "added_time_goals_in_end_matches": 287,
      "added_time_goals_per_added_minute": 0.0332,
      "label": "5 subs + new added time: 2023-24 to 2025-26",
      "subs": "5",
      "added_time": "new"
    },
    "F": {
      "matches": 50,
      "goals": 141,
      "goals_per_match": 2.82,
      "after_75": 32,
      "after_75_share": 22.7,
      "reg_76_90": 22,
      "reg_76_90_share": 15.6,
      "reg_76_90_per_match": 0.44,
      "added_time_goals": 10,
      "added_time_share": 7.1,
      "added_time_per_match": 0.2,
      "matches_with_end": 50,
      "mean_end_minute": 6.2,
      "end_minute_sum": 308,
      "added_time_goals_in_end_matches": 10,
      "added_time_goals_per_added_minute": 0.0325,
      "label": "2026-27 to 20 September (partial)",
      "subs": "5",
      "added_time": "new"
    }
  },
  "seasons": {
    "2016-17": {
      "matches": 378,
      "goals": 1058,
      "goals_per_match": 2.8,
      "after_75": 248,
      "after_75_share": 23.4,
      "reg_76_90": 180,
      "reg_76_90_share": 17.0,
      "reg_76_90_per_match": 0.476,
      "added_time_goals": 68,
      "added_time_share": 6.4,
      "added_time_per_match": 0.18,
      "matches_with_end": 378,
      "mean_end_minute": 5.1,
      "end_minute_sum": 1927,
      "added_time_goals_in_end_matches": 68,
      "added_time_goals_per_added_minute": 0.0353
    },
    "2017-18": {
      "matches": 380,
      "goals": 1018,
      "goals_per_match": 2.68,
      "after_75": 228,
      "after_75_share": 22.4,
      "reg_76_90": 179,
      "reg_76_90_share": 17.6,
      "reg_76_90_per_match": 0.471,
      "added_time_goals": 49,
      "added_time_share": 4.8,
      "added_time_per_match": 0.129,
      "matches_with_end": 380,
      "mean_end_minute": 5.0,
      "end_minute_sum": 1893,
      "added_time_goals_in_end_matches": 49,
      "added_time_goals_per_added_minute": 0.0259
    },
    "2018-19": {
      "matches": 380,
      "goals": 1072,
      "goals_per_match": 2.82,
      "after_75": 253,
      "after_75_share": 23.6,
      "reg_76_90": 181,
      "reg_76_90_share": 16.9,
      "reg_76_90_per_match": 0.476,
      "added_time_goals": 72,
      "added_time_share": 6.7,
      "added_time_per_match": 0.189,
      "matches_with_end": 379,
      "mean_end_minute": 5.2,
      "end_minute_sum": 1974,
      "added_time_goals_in_end_matches": 72,
      "added_time_goals_per_added_minute": 0.0365
    },
    "2019-20 to March": {
      "matches": 288,
      "goals": 784,
      "goals_per_match": 2.72,
      "after_75": 167,
      "after_75_share": 21.3,
      "reg_76_90": 128,
      "reg_76_90_share": 16.3,
      "reg_76_90_per_match": 0.444,
      "added_time_goals": 39,
      "added_time_share": 5.0,
      "added_time_per_match": 0.135,
      "matches_with_end": 288,
      "mean_end_minute": 5.5,
      "end_minute_sum": 1581,
      "added_time_goals_in_end_matches": 39,
      "added_time_goals_per_added_minute": 0.0247
    },
    "2019-20 restart": {
      "matches": 92,
      "goals": 250,
      "goals_per_match": 2.72,
      "after_75": 56,
      "after_75_share": 22.4,
      "reg_76_90": 44,
      "reg_76_90_share": 17.6,
      "reg_76_90_per_match": 0.478,
      "added_time_goals": 12,
      "added_time_share": 4.8,
      "added_time_per_match": 0.13,
      "matches_with_end": 92,
      "mean_end_minute": 5.8,
      "end_minute_sum": 535,
      "added_time_goals_in_end_matches": 12,
      "added_time_goals_per_added_minute": 0.0224
    },
    "2020-21": {
      "matches": 380,
      "goals": 1024,
      "goals_per_match": 2.69,
      "after_75": 218,
      "after_75_share": 21.3,
      "reg_76_90": 168,
      "reg_76_90_share": 16.4,
      "reg_76_90_per_match": 0.442,
      "added_time_goals": 50,
      "added_time_share": 4.9,
      "added_time_per_match": 0.132,
      "matches_with_end": 380,
      "mean_end_minute": 5.1,
      "end_minute_sum": 1920,
      "added_time_goals_in_end_matches": 50,
      "added_time_goals_per_added_minute": 0.026
    },
    "2021-22": {
      "matches": 380,
      "goals": 1071,
      "goals_per_match": 2.82,
      "after_75": 241,
      "after_75_share": 22.5,
      "reg_76_90": 169,
      "reg_76_90_share": 15.8,
      "reg_76_90_per_match": 0.445,
      "added_time_goals": 72,
      "added_time_share": 6.7,
      "added_time_per_match": 0.189,
      "matches_with_end": 380,
      "mean_end_minute": 5.4,
      "end_minute_sum": 2051,
      "added_time_goals_in_end_matches": 72,
      "added_time_goals_per_added_minute": 0.0351
    },
    "2022-23": {
      "matches": 380,
      "goals": 1084,
      "goals_per_match": 2.85,
      "after_75": 217,
      "after_75_share": 20.0,
      "reg_76_90": 168,
      "reg_76_90_share": 15.5,
      "reg_76_90_per_match": 0.442,
      "added_time_goals": 49,
      "added_time_share": 4.5,
      "added_time_per_match": 0.129,
      "matches_with_end": 380,
      "mean_end_minute": 6.1,
      "end_minute_sum": 2324,
      "added_time_goals_in_end_matches": 49,
      "added_time_goals_per_added_minute": 0.0211
    },
    "2023-24": {
      "matches": 380,
      "goals": 1246,
      "goals_per_match": 3.28,
      "after_75": 307,
      "after_75_share": 24.6,
      "reg_76_90": 204,
      "reg_76_90_share": 16.4,
      "reg_76_90_per_match": 0.537,
      "added_time_goals": 103,
      "added_time_share": 8.3,
      "added_time_per_match": 0.271,
      "matches_with_end": 380,
      "mean_end_minute": 8.1,
      "end_minute_sum": 3065,
      "added_time_goals_in_end_matches": 103,
      "added_time_goals_per_added_minute": 0.0336
    },
    "2024-25": {
      "matches": 380,
      "goals": 1115,
      "goals_per_match": 2.93,
      "after_75": 252,
      "after_75_share": 22.6,
      "reg_76_90": 172,
      "reg_76_90_share": 15.4,
      "reg_76_90_per_match": 0.453,
      "added_time_goals": 80,
      "added_time_share": 7.2,
      "added_time_per_match": 0.211,
      "matches_with_end": 380,
      "mean_end_minute": 7.1,
      "end_minute_sum": 2706,
      "added_time_goals_in_end_matches": 80,
      "added_time_goals_per_added_minute": 0.0296
    },
    "2025-26": {
      "matches": 380,
      "goals": 1045,
      "goals_per_match": 2.75,
      "after_75": 270,
      "after_75_share": 25.8,
      "reg_76_90": 166,
      "reg_76_90_share": 15.9,
      "reg_76_90_per_match": 0.437,
      "added_time_goals": 104,
      "added_time_share": 10.0,
      "added_time_per_match": 0.274,
      "matches_with_end": 380,
      "mean_end_minute": 7.5,
      "end_minute_sum": 2863,
      "added_time_goals_in_end_matches": 104,
      "added_time_goals_per_added_minute": 0.0363
    },
    "2026-27": {
      "matches": 50,
      "goals": 141,
      "goals_per_match": 2.82,
      "after_75": 32,
      "after_75_share": 22.7,
      "reg_76_90": 22,
      "reg_76_90_share": 15.6,
      "reg_76_90_per_match": 0.44,
      "added_time_goals": 10,
      "added_time_share": 7.1,
      "added_time_per_match": 0.2,
      "matches_with_end": 50,
      "mean_end_minute": 6.2,
      "end_minute_sum": 308,
      "added_time_goals_in_end_matches": 10,
      "added_time_goals_per_added_minute": 0.0325
    }
  },
  "tests": {
    "D_vs_C_after_75_share": {
      "diff_pts": -1.9,
      "ci_pts": [
        -4.9,
        1.1
      ]
    },
    "D_vs_C_reg_76_90_share": {
      "diff_pts": -0.6,
      "ci_pts": [
        -3.3,
        2.1
      ]
    },
    "D_vs_C_reg_76_90_per_match": {
      "rates": [
        0.443,
        0.442
      ],
      "diff": -0.001,
      "ci": [
        -0.083,
        0.081
      ]
    },
    "E_vs_D_after_75_share": {
      "diff_pts": 4.3,
      "ci_pts": [
        1.5,
        7.1
      ]
    },
    "E_vs_D_reg_76_90_share": {
      "diff_pts": 0.4,
      "ci_pts": [
        -2.1,
        2.9
      ]
    },
    "E_vs_D_added_time_share": {
      "diff_pts": 3.9,
      "ci_pts": [
        2.4,
        5.5
      ]
    },
    "E_vs_D_added_time_per_match": {
      "rates": [
        0.129,
        0.252
      ],
      "diff": 0.123,
      "ci": [
        0.076,
        0.169
      ]
    },
    "per_added_minute_pre_2023": 0.0289,
    "per_added_minute_pre_2023_n": [
      411,
      14205
    ],
    "per_added_minute_E": 0.0332,
    "per_added_minute_E_n": [
      287,
      8634
    ],
    "pre_2023_mean_end_minute": 5.3,
    "pre_2023_matches_with_end": 2657,
    "pre_2023_added_time_per_match": 0.155,
    "E_added_time_goals_at_pre_rate": 250,
    "E_added_time_goals_at_pre_per_match": 176,
    "per_100_added_minutes_E_vs_pre": {
      "rates": [
        2.89,
        3.32
      ],
      "diff": 0.43,
      "ci": [
        -0.04,
        0.91
      ]
    },
    "E_extra_added_time_goals": 111,
    "E_extra_from_length": 74,
    "pre_2023_matches": 2658,
    "pre_2023_added_time_goals": 411,
    "reg_76_90_share_range_full_seasons": [
      15.4,
      17.6
    ],
    "after_75_share_lowest_season": "2022-23"
  },
  "charts": [
    {
      "file": "/images/charts/epl_five_subs_late_goals.png",
      "alt": "Two stacked panels by Premier League season, 2016-17 to 2026-27, with Project Restart and 2019-20 before it shown separately and the five-substitution periods shaded. Top: the share of all goals scored after the 75th minute, split into regulation minutes 76 to 90 (green) and second-half added time (gold). The green part stays between 15.4% and 17.6% in every full season, including 2022-23, the first permanent five-sub season, when the total was 20.0%. The gold part grows from 2023-24, when added time changed: 8.3%, 7.2% and 10.0%. Bottom: the second half ended on average at 90+5.0 to 90+6.1 in each season up to 2022-23 and at 90+8.1, 90+7.1 and 90+7.5 after."
    }
  ]
}