{
  "slug": "how-win-probability-models-work",
  "section": "calibration",
  "title": "A 2025-26 Poisson model graded on 2026-27",
  "source": "ESPN public scoreboard (soccer/eng.1), data_layer/epl_2025_26_results.json (pulled 2026-08-21) and data_layer/epl_2026_27_results.json (pulled 2026-11-01 18:27 UTC)",
  "model": "independent Poisson, attack x defence x home advantage, maximum likelihood on 2025-26; promoted clubs = league-average ratings; scoreline grid 0-10",
  "charts": [
    "/images/charts/epl_poisson_calibration_2026_27.png"
  ],
  "stats": {
    "fit_matches": 380,
    "fit_retrieved": "2026-08-21",
    "fit_home_draw_away": [
      162,
      104,
      114
    ],
    "fit_rates": [
      0.4263157894736842,
      0.2736842105263158,
      0.3
    ],
    "fit_home_goals_per_match": 1.5263157894736843,
    "fit_away_goals_per_match": 1.2236842105263157,
    "gamma": 1.2473118279569486,
    "test_matches": 89,
    "test_retrieved": "2026-11-01",
    "test_first": "2026-08-21T19:00Z",
    "test_last": "2026-11-01T16:30Z",
    "test_home_draw_away": [
      36,
      25,
      28
    ],
    "test_mean_forecast": [
      0.4435179490646075,
      0.24569053376481684,
      0.3107915171705756
    ],
    "promoted": [
      "Coventry City",
      "Hull City",
      "Ipswich Town"
    ],
    "relegated": [
      "Burnley",
      "West Ham United",
      "Wolverhampton Wanderers"
    ],
    "promoted_matches": 25,
    "other_matches": 64,
    "brier": {
      "model": 0.6104114149423241,
      "base_rate": 0.6592442964300165,
      "uniform": 0.6666666666666667,
      "model_relegated_rule": 0.6141483158566164
    },
    "logloss": {
      "model": 1.0217281028535679,
      "base_rate": 1.087622970676094,
      "uniform": 1.0986122886681098
    },
    "skill_vs_base_rate": 0.07407402953978581,
    "skill_vs_uniform": 0.08438287758651397,
    "brier_diff_vs_base_rate": {
      "diff": -0.048832881487692395,
      "se": 0.020262851796629452,
      "lo": -0.08854807100908613,
      "hi": -0.00911769196629867
    },
    "brier_diff_vs_uniform": {
      "diff": -0.05625525172434263,
      "se": 0.027057775739238184,
      "lo": -0.10928849217324946,
      "hi": -0.003222011275435789
    },
    "logloss_diff_vs_base_rate": {
      "diff": -0.06589486782252629,
      "se": 0.028562131615925655,
      "lo": -0.12187664578974058,
      "hi": -0.009913089855312009
    },
    "brier_promoted": {
      "model": 0.5778509775414444,
      "base_rate": 0.6279113573407202
    },
    "brier_other": {
      "model": 0.6231303358020428,
      "base_rate": 0.6714837257617728
    },
    "draw_forecast_min": 0.1759343529999589,
    "draw_forecast_max": 0.29305253728224406,
    "fit_in_sample_mean_draw_forecast": 0.23741283219097042,
    "favourite_hits": 42,
    "favourite_counts_home_draw_away": [
      74,
      0,
      15
    ],
    "home_forecast_min": 0.16164916761428907,
    "home_forecast_max": 0.7339776438475615
  },
  "ratings": {
    "AFC Bournemouth": {
      "attack": 1.1140204240448475,
      "defence": 1.2723040410657032
    },
    "Arsenal": {
      "attack": 1.3276747932496618,
      "defence": 0.643431063563667
    },
    "Aston Villa": {
      "attack": 1.0700408238921342,
      "defence": 1.1518158886848644
    },
    "Brentford": {
      "attack": 1.0540782921729746,
      "defence": 1.2213053731401629
    },
    "Brighton & Hove Albion": {
      "attack": 0.9904175364366344,
      "defence": 1.0767674440385813
    },
    "Burnley": {
      "attack": 0.7446904778341157,
      "defence": 1.733194976856128
    },
    "Chelsea": {
      "attack": 1.1117520350362886,
      "defence": 1.2250345306659811
    },
    "Crystal Palace": {
      "attack": 0.7844060542026331,
      "defence": 1.1810085063371305
    },
    "Everton": {
      "attack": 0.8985698847204376,
      "defence": 1.1647716267042603
    },
    "Fulham": {
      "attack": 0.8994723305561094,
      "defence": 1.1881231920420385
    },
    "Leeds United": {
      "attack": 0.9425895288810925,
      "defence": 1.3075575154791275
    },
    "Liverpool": {
      "attack": 1.2091569196859098,
      "defence": 1.2550651376640003
    },
    "Manchester City": {
      "attack": 1.4518450926051558,
      "defence": 0.839661020580391
    },
    "Manchester United": {
      "attack": 1.3206705722780714,
      "defence": 1.1910922131247683
    },
    "Newcastle United": {
      "attack": 1.018734186369255,
      "defence": 1.2893599642312672
    },
    "Nottingham Forest": {
      "attack": 0.9186572372195395,
      "defence": 1.189317763767276
    },
    "Sunderland": {
      "attack": 0.8011782981192581,
      "defence": 1.1125084656913866
    },
    "Tottenham Hotspur": {
      "attack": 0.9242347624242944,
      "defence": 1.3296261538004015
    },
    "West Ham United": {
      "attack": 0.8928385044602937,
      "defence": 1.5137489146584782
    },
    "Wolverhampton Wanderers": {
      "attack": 0.5249722458112945,
      "defence": 1.5537011596419736
    }
  },
  "tables": {
    "reliability": [
      {
        "outcome": "Home win",
        "bin": "Under 25%",
        "n": 6,
        "mean_forecast": 0.19193813567130016,
        "observed": 0.16666666666666666,
        "hits": 1,
        "wilson_lo": 0.03005258587173032,
        "wilson_hi": 0.563509436563646
      },
      {
        "outcome": "Home win",
        "bin": "25% to 40%",
        "n": 21,
        "mean_forecast": 0.3565804362010677,
        "observed": 0.23809523809523808,
        "hits": 5,
        "wilson_lo": 0.10627856389112261,
        "wilson_hi": 0.45091581972345923
      },
      {
        "outcome": "Home win",
        "bin": "40% to 55%",
        "n": 50,
        "mean_forecast": 0.4581584652687854,
        "observed": 0.42,
        "hits": 21,
        "wilson_lo": 0.2937479723456693,
        "wilson_hi": 0.5576680331222217
      },
      {
        "outcome": "Home win",
        "bin": "55% and over",
        "n": 12,
        "mean_forecast": 0.6604463524217147,
        "observed": 0.75,
        "hits": 9,
        "wilson_lo": 0.46768966087934005,
        "wilson_hi": 0.9110599603710386
      },
      {
        "outcome": "Draw",
        "bin": "Under 25%",
        "n": 43,
        "mean_forecast": 0.22679238875222948,
        "observed": 0.3023255813953488,
        "hits": 13,
        "wilson_lo": 0.18601827946182872,
        "wilson_hi": 0.4510564575240983
      },
      {
        "outcome": "Draw",
        "bin": "25% to 40%",
        "n": 46,
        "mean_forecast": 0.26335619105919195,
        "observed": 0.2608695652173913,
        "hits": 12,
        "wilson_lo": 0.15600735194449333,
        "wilson_hi": 0.402594298082793
      },
      {
        "outcome": "Away win",
        "bin": "Under 25%",
        "n": 20,
        "mean_forecast": 0.18190119279896863,
        "observed": 0.15,
        "hits": 3,
        "wilson_lo": 0.05236779195949584,
        "wilson_hi": 0.36042329588695743
      },
      {
        "outcome": "Away win",
        "bin": "25% to 40%",
        "n": 56,
        "mean_forecast": 0.3128882796472734,
        "observed": 0.32142857142857145,
        "hits": 18,
        "wilson_lo": 0.21400827887722298,
        "wilson_hi": 0.45177605843996116
      },
      {
        "outcome": "Away win",
        "bin": "40% to 55%",
        "n": 10,
        "mean_forecast": 0.47654155772898427,
        "observed": 0.4,
        "hits": 4,
        "wilson_lo": 0.16817758120350967,
        "wilson_hi": 0.6873304525498135
      },
      {
        "outcome": "Away win",
        "bin": "55% and over",
        "n": 3,
        "mean_forecast": 0.5784206448882356,
        "observed": 1.0,
        "hits": 3,
        "wilson_lo": 0.43849391955098227,
        "wilson_hi": 1.0
      }
    ]
  }
}