"He won the most headers" is the kind of sentence worth distrusting. It sounds like a verdict and it's usually just a head count. A player can win fifteen of twenty-five and look commanding on the box score while a quieter team-mate wins eight of ten and is, in fact, the far better aerial presence: the rate says so even when the raw total shouts the opposite. That gap is the whole problem with heading data: the count answers a question (how often was this player in the air?) that is almost never the one you actually meant to ask.
So before trusting any aerial number, ask two things the headline figure hides: how many duels stand behind it, and what the player was being asked to do in the first place. Get those straight and the data becomes one of the more readable stats in the sport. Skip them and it will fool you every time.
What an aerial duel is, and what win % measures
An aerial duel is logged when two opposing players jump to contest the same ball in the air and one of them wins it: gets a head or other legal touch that directs the ball or denies the opponent. The event is recorded for both players, one as a win and one as a loss, so aerial duels come in matched pairs. From those events come two numbers that are constantly confused: the count of duels won, and the win percentage.
The count tells you how many a player won; the rate tells you how good they were at winning the ones they contested. They are different questions with different answers.
The win percentage is the quality measure. A win rate above roughly 60% marks a genuinely dominant aerial player, and the most commanding centre-backs push higher still; forwards and wingers, who usually jump with a defender behind them, sit well below half as groups (the 2022 World Cup figures are in the next section). But the rate alone is incomplete, which is the heart of the problem.
What the 2022 World Cup shows: aerial win rate against volume, every duel counted
To test the volume trap on real matches, we counted every aerial duel at the 2022 World Cup in StatsBomb Open Data (StatsBomb Public Data User Agreement): all 64 matches' event files, retrieved June 4, 2026. StatsBomb logs the loser of each duel as an "Aerial Lost" event and links it to the winner's touch (a headed pass, clearance, shot or miscontrol), so every duel has exactly one winner and one loser. Shoot-outs are left out. A player's position is the one StatsBomb records on his duel events.
The tournament had 2,204 aerial duels, 34.4 a match, contested by 576 players. The median player among them contested 6 in the whole tournament, and the most was 44 (Nicolás Otamendi and Olivier Giroud). Among the 177 players with at least 10 duels, the number contested and the share won are almost unrelated: r = 0.09. Volume told you how often a player was in the air, and very little about how often he won.
| Player | Team | Position group | Duels | Won | Win % | Win-rate rank (of 31) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nicolás Hernán Otamendi | Argentina | Centre-back | 44 | 27 | 61.4% | 10 |
| Dejan Lovren | Croatia | Centre-back | 32 | 25 | 78.1% | 1 |
| Olivier Giroud | France | Forward | 44 | 25 | 56.8% | 14 |
| Harry Maguire | England | Centre-back | 29 | 22 | 75.9% | 3 |
| Youssef En-Nesyri | Morocco | Forward | 41 | 22 | 53.7% | 21 |
| Gue-Sung Cho | South Korea | Forward | 37 | 21 | 56.8% | 15 |
| Joachim Andersen | Denmark | Centre-back | 27 | 18 | 66.7% | 6 |
| Virgil van Dijk | Netherlands | Centre-back | 28 | 18 | 64.3% | 8 |
| Ivan Perišić | Croatia | Attacking midfield / winger | 33 | 18 | 54.5% | 20 |
| Robert Lewandowski | Poland | Forward | 39 | 18 | 46.2% | 28 |
Only 5 of the 10 leaders by duels won are also in the top ten by win rate, and all five are centre-backs: Dejan Lovren, Harry Maguire, Joachim Andersen, Otamendi and Virgil van Dijk. The forwards on the list are there on volume. Robert Lewandowski won 18 of 39 (46.2%), 28th of the 31 players with 20 or more duels; Youssef En-Nesyri won 22 of 41 (53.7%), 21st.
| Position group | Duels | Won | Win % |
|---|---|---|---|
| Centre-back | 1,155 | 733 | 63.5% |
| Defensive midfield | 578 | 331 | 57.3% |
| Full-back / wing-back | 705 | 393 | 55.7% |
| Central / wide midfield | 379 | 153 | 40.4% |
| Forward | 987 | 393 | 39.8% |
| Attacking midfield / winger | 604 | 201 | 33.3% |
Position is the biggest effect in the data. Centre-backs won 63.5% of their aerial duels; forwards won 39.8%, and attacking midfielders and wingers 33.3%. Much of that is the shape of the contest: the defender usually faces the ball as it arrives, and the forward usually has his back to goal with a marker behind him. So compare a striker's rate with other strikers. Giroud's 56.8% (25 of 44) was the best of the 13 forwards with 20 or more duels, and 10 of the 11 centre-backs with 20 or more duels beat it.
How much is skill, and how much is a small sample? A World Cup is short. Lovren had the best rate of anyone with 20 or more duels, 25 of 32 (78.1%), but a 95% Wilson interval around that rate runs from 61.2% to 89.0%. Across the 31 players with 20 or more duels, win rates spread around their own position group's rate by 8.6 percentage points (standard deviation); coin-flip luck alone, at those volumes, would produce 9.6. Within a position, one tournament of duels cannot separate the players. That takes a season or more.
Where the duels happen. 26.9% of the aerial duels came in possessions that started from a corner or a free kick. Regular-play possessions held 638, throw-ins 487 and goal kicks 353. Inside the penalty areas, set pieces were close to a coin flip: in corner and free-kick possessions, defenders won 147 of the box aerials and attackers 148. In open play, defenders won 111 to the attackers' 84 (56.9%). A side with a real aerial edge at set pieces is beating an even contest, which is why it pays.
Winning the header is not winning the ball. Leaving out the 129 headed shots, we followed each won aerial to the next on-ball action in the same half (restarts count). The duel winner's team made that action only 42.5% of the time (880 of 2,072). Headed passes found their own side 47.7% of the time, and headed clearances 31.6%, which is often all a clearance is for. That is the second-ball problem described below, measured: a won duel more often ended with the other team on the ball.
Reproduce it. Our analysis script computes every figure in this section, and draws the chart, from the June 2026 event files. Its output is in /data/stats/aerial-duels-and-heading-data.json. Limits: one tournament of national-team football, StatsBomb's own definition of a duel, and no record of how high or how contested each jump was.
Why raw counts mislead: the volume trap
Raw aerial counts are driven as much by a player's role and his team's style as by his ability. Consider the ways the count deceives.
Volume is a function of role, not skill. A target striker in a side that plays direct can contest a dozen or more aerials in a match; a deep-lying playmaker in a possession team might contest one. The striker can win more headers in absolute terms while being a worse aerial player by rate, simply because he is thrown into far more contests. Ranking players by headers won is therefore largely a ranking of how often their team puts the ball in the air near them, which is to say, not much of a ranking of aerial ability at all.
Team style inflates and deflates the denominator. Play against a team that launches long balls all game and your centre-backs rack up aerial duels by the dozen; play a patient short-passing side and the same defenders barely jump. The opponent, not the player, sets much of the volume.
Rate without volume is fragile. The opposite error is just as easy. A player who contests three aerials and wins all three posts a glittering 100% win rate built on almost nothing. A rate is only as trustworthy as the number of duels behind it: a handful of contests is noise, not a measured skill.
Where aerial dominance actually matters
Aerial ability is not uniformly valuable across the pitch: it concentrates in a few situations where heading the ball is the decisive act, and those are the places to weight it.
Set pieces, both ends. Corners and attacking free-kicks are the purest test of attacking aerial ability: a player who reliably wins his header in the box converts dead-ball volume into chances, and the same player at the other end heads them clear. Set-piece aerial duels are higher-leverage than open-play ones because each contest is closer to a shot. (For the broader value of dead-ball situations, see long throw-ins as a set-piece weapon.)
Target men and the direct outlet. A striker who holds up long balls lets a team bypass midfield pressure and play forward under duress. His aerial win rate against the opposing centre-backs is the engine of that outlet, not for the goals he heads, but for the possessions he wins or retains by getting a touch.
Defending crosses. The defensive value is enormous and easy to undercount. A centre-back who wins his aerials when crosses come in is suppressing chances before they become shots: work that never shows up as a tackle or an interception but shapes how much danger an opponent's wide play produces. Defending the cross is where aerial dominance quietly prevents goals.
Reading the data well
Put the cautions together and a sensible workflow emerges. Start with win percentage, but only trust it once the volume behind it is large enough to mean something: a season of duels, not an afternoon. Compare players within the same position and role, because a striker's aerial profile and a holding midfielder's are not on the same scale. Split by phase where the data allows: a player's set-piece aerial rate and his open-play rate can differ sharply, and the set-piece number is often the one that matters. Read defensive aerials as chance suppression, not as a counting stat, and resist the box-score reflex that rewards the player who jumped the most rather than the one who won what he jumped for.
One more refinement, and it's the one that matters most: aerial win rate says nothing about what happened to the ball after the header. Winning a flick that loops straight to an opponent is logged identically to winning a header that sets up a team-mate. The richest aerial analysis pairs the duel win with the outcome of the second ball (whose team kept possession after the header), which is closer to the thing that actually matters than the duel result on its own.
The bottom line
Aerial-duel data is a small case study in the difference between counting and measuring. The count, headers won, is mostly a record of opportunity, set by a player's role and his opponents' style. The rate, win percentage, is the quality signal, but only once enough duels stand behind it and only once you compare like with like. Weight it where it pays: dead balls at both ends, the direct outlet up front, the cross coming into your own box. Read the two numbers together, attach the outcome of the second ball when you can, and the player who merely spends a lot of time in the air stops being mistaken for the player who actually owns it.
Sources & data
- FBref: aerial duels won, lost, and win % across competitions (via Opta).
- StatsBomb: event definitions for aerial duels and set-piece data.
- StatsBomb Open Data (StatsBomb Public Data User Agreement): the 2022 World Cup event files (64 matches, retrieved June 4, 2026) behind the computed section; event-level data for computing aerial rates yourself. Our results: /data/stats/aerial-duels-and-heading-data.json.
- Defensive actions: tackles and interceptions, the same volume-vs-rate lessons for other defensive stats.
Published by SoccerAnalytics from public data and the sources named in this piece. How this site is made.