Few instructions in football feel as natural as “get it wide and put it in the box.” It looks like attacking: bodies in the area, a ball whipped in, a striker rising to meet it. Count what actually happens to crosses, as we did for every open-play cross of the 2022 World Cup, and the picture is less flattering. Most crosses never reach a teammate, most of the ones that do never become a shot, and the high ball into the box, the delivery the instruction usually means, was worth less than half as much as a cut-back.
What 1,372 World Cup crosses show
We counted every open-play cross in the 64 matches of the 2022 World Cup in StatsBomb Open Data (StatsBomb Public Data User Agreement): passes StatsBomb flags as crosses, leaving out the corner, free-kick and throw-in deliveries themselves and the penalty shoot-outs. That leaves 1,372 crosses, 21.4 a match, or 10.7 per team per match.
About one in three found a teammate. 429 of the 1,372 were completed, 31.3%. The rest were cut out or went astray (827 incomplete), went out of play (90) or ended offside or unresolved (26). That is better than the “one in five” that often gets quoted for crossing, and the gap is a reminder that the figure depends on the provider and on what counts as a cross and a completion: this is StatsBomb’s definition, at one tournament. By this count, two crosses in three failed.
About one in six led straight to a shot. 226 crosses (16.5%) were the pass immediately before a shot, and 41 of those shots were goals: one goal for every 33.5 crosses. Counting any shot the crossing team took later in the same possession, however many passes later, raises the share only to 31.0% (426 crosses).
The shots themselves were not poor; there were just too few of them. A shot set up by a cross averaged 0.135 expected goals, against 0.080 for the 670 other open-play shots set up by a pass. That surprises people, but the reason is simple: a cross that is met is met close to goal, while many other assisted shots are struck from the edge of the box or further out. The weak half is the header. 99 of the 226 cross-assisted shots were headed (43.8%) and averaged 0.106 xG (17 goals); the 123 struck with the foot averaged 0.151 (23 goals). An expected-goals model weighs distance, angle and body part, and a header from a ball arriving across the body at pace, with a defender and goalkeeper contesting it, is one of the harder finishes in the game. Taken across every delivery, the 1,372 crosses produced 30.6 xG between them, 0.022 xG per cross.
These are one tournament’s figures from one provider, and a league season would give different numbers. But the shape is clear: the cross loses mostly on frequency, not on the quality of the chance it creates when it works, and the high ball is where the losses are largest.
Five ways into the box, measured
To see where the cross stands, we split the open-play deliveries into the box at the same tournament into five kinds. StatsBomb tags cut-backs (passes pulled back from near the byline) separately, and 86 of the 124 open-play cut-backs are also tagged as crosses, so we count them once, as cut-backs, and leave them out of the two cross rows.
| Delivery | Passes | Completed | Led to a shot | xG per shot | xG per pass | Goals |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| High crosses (not cut-backs) | 905 | 30.4% | 14.9% | 0.110 | 0.016 | 22 |
| Low and ground crosses (not cut-backs) | 381 | 31.2% | 17.6% | 0.177 | 0.031 | 13 |
| Cut-backs | 124 | 45.2% | 22.6% | 0.153 | 0.035 | 7 |
| Through balls | 249 | 31.7% | 16.5% | 0.225 | 0.037 | 13 |
| Other passes into the box | 1,988 | 39.2% | 11.4% | 0.122 | 0.014 | 33 |
The high cross was by far the most common kind of cross and among the least rewarding deliveries: 905 of them, 14.9% leading to a shot worth 0.110 xG on average, 0.016 xG per pass. A cut-back was worth more than twice as much per delivery, 0.035: it found a teammate 45.2% of the time and set up a shot 22.6% of the time. Low and ground crosses (0.031 per pass) and through balls (0.037) sit with the cut-back. The high cross asks a teammate to win an aerial duel and then beat a set goalkeeper, usually with his head: two hard things in sequence. The cut-back asks him to side-foot a ball rolling across the area, often at a goal the keeper has been dragged away from. One honest qualification: the ordinary pass into the box, the 1,988 that were none of the above, was worth no more than the high cross (0.014 per pass), so the lesson is not that crossing is uniquely bad but that the kind of delivery matters more than the label.
Who crossed most, and what it bought
The teams at each end of the crossing table show why volume alone says little. The four sides that crossed most per match and the four that crossed least:
| Team | Matches | Crosses per match | Completed | Shots set up | xG from crosses | Per match |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Croatia | 7 | 14.9 | 31.7% | 13 | 1.66 | 0.24 |
| Mexico | 3 | 14.7 | 27.3% | 4 | 0.85 | 0.28 |
| Brazil | 5 | 14.6 | 27.4% | 12 | 1.37 | 0.27 |
| Germany | 3 | 14.3 | 41.9% | 11 | 2.22 | 0.74 |
| Saudi Arabia | 3 | 7.3 | 27.3% | 3 | 0.19 | 0.06 |
| Poland | 4 | 7.2 | 48.3% | 8 | 0.79 | 0.20 |
| Morocco | 7 | 7.1 | 32.0% | 9 | 1.12 | 0.16 |
| Costa Rica | 3 | 5.3 | 25.0% | 1 | 0.10 | 0.03 |
The two heaviest crossers, Croatia (14.9 a match) and Mexico (14.7), completed fewer than a third of them and got about a quarter of an expected goal per match out of the habit (0.24 and 0.28). Germany crossed almost as often (14.3) but completed 41.9% and drew 0.74 xG a match from crosses, the most of any side, without getting out of their group. At the other end, Morocco crossed only 7.1 times a match and reached the semi-finals; Costa Rica, the lightest crossers at 5.3, set up one shot from a cross in three matches. Serbia shows the other trap: 13.0 crosses a match, 28.2% completed, and 0.27 xG from crosses across their three matches.
Volume is not a sign of a bad attack either. Across all 32 teams, crosses per match correlate at r = 0.56 with non-penalty xG per match, because the sides that cross most are mostly the sides that spend most time near the opponent’s box. What separates them is the return on each delivery, not the count.
So why does “get it wide and cross it” persist?
If crossing is so inefficient, its stubborn popularity needs explaining, and there are honest reasons for it. The first is that the wide areas are simply easier to reach. Defences protect the centre of the pitch most fiercely; the touchline is where space is conceded, so possession naturally drifts wide, and once the ball is there a cross is the most available next action. Working a clean central chance is more valuable but also much harder to engineer against a compact block.
The second is salience. A cross that does produce a thumping header is vivid and memorable; the five in six that never become a shot are forgotten. Coaches, crowds and commentators remember the goal, not the denominator. The third is that a cross is a low-risk turnover: a ball lofted into the box rarely leads to a dangerous counter the way a lost ball in central midfield can, so a cautious side may cross precisely because it is a tidy way to end a possession. None of this makes the average cross efficient: it makes it convenient, safe, and easy to remember, which is not the same thing.
When crossing actually makes sense
The analytics case is against the indiscriminate high cross, not against putting the ball into the box full stop. Several situations turn crossing from a poor option into a good one, and they are worth naming precisely because the blanket stat hides them.
- Cut-backs and low balls from the byline. This is the big one. A pass pulled back from the goal line to a runner arriving at the penalty spot is one of the most valuable patterns in the game: the shooter is square to goal, the keeper is often out of position, and the chance is taken with the feet. At the 2022 World Cup a cut-back was worth 0.035 xG per delivery against 0.016 for a high cross. A cut-back is often tagged as a cross, but it has almost nothing in common with a hopeful ball from deep.
- Low, driven crosses over floated ones. A hard ball across the face of goal is harder to defend and can be turned in first-time, whereas a high, hanging cross gives defenders and the keeper time to set and attack it. At the same tournament, shots from low and ground crosses averaged 0.177 xG against 0.110 from high ones. The trajectory matters as much as the delivery point.
- A genuinely packed box, or a mismatch. If you have numbers and aerial dominance in the area (multiple tall arrivals against a stretched defence), a high cross becomes a better proposition, because you are no longer asking one striker to beat the whole back line alone.
- Set-piece deliveries. A dead ball is a different proposition. The delivery is unopposed, attackers can be choreographed onto it, and the value of a good set-piece ball is well understood: see set-piece xG for why a corner or wide free-kick is not the same gamble as an open-play cross at all.
The geometry of the cut-back, and how to find it in the data
The cut-back's power comes from three things happening at once. The defence is facing the wrong way: when an attacker reaches the byline, the defensive line and the goalkeeper turn to track the ball toward their own goal, ball-watching, side-on or with their backs to the runners arriving behind them, and the pull-back is played into exactly that blind side. The goalkeeper is pinned to the near post: as the ball travels to the byline he shuffles across to guard the near post, so a ball pulled back to the penalty spot is struck at a goal whose keeper is several yards out of position and moving the wrong way. The shooter is square to goal: a ball at the byline sits at a near-zero shooting angle, and pulling it back a few yards to a central runner trades that dead angle for an open one, in effect, a manufactured central chance.
Some event data labels the cut-back directly: StatsBomb's carries a cut-back flag on the pass, which is what the table above uses. Where there is no flag, analysts reconstruct it from coordinates. Look for completed passes that start very close to the byline and travel backwards relative to goal into the central zone around the penalty spot; for assists and key passes that lead to central, footed shots rather than headers or tight-angle efforts; for sides that reach the byline often and turn those entries into high-xG central chances; and for shot-creating actions from the wide channels paired with location, which separate teams that cut the ball back from teams that float it in.
It is also why the move is so hard to defend. Step out to block the cut-back and you leave the back post; drop to cover the runners and you concede the byline; commit the keeper and you open the near post. The best defences stop the move before the byline, preventing the wide entry in the first place, because once an attacker is square on the goal-line with a runner arriving, the geometry has already turned against them.
How to read crossing numbers
The practical lesson is to never read crossing volume on its own. A high crosses-attempted figure tells you a team’s style, not its effectiveness: it can mean a side is creating overloads and cut-backs, or it can mean a side is reaching the byline and then giving up on the move with a low-percentage ball. The three numbers only mean something together: volume (how often they cross), completion (how often it finds a teammate), and the xG that results (whether the chances are any good). Germany and Croatia crossed at almost the same rate in Qatar; per match, Germany drew three times as much xG from it.
The better diagnostic is to separate cut-backs and low deliveries from floated high crosses, and to look at the xG per cross rather than the raw count. A side whose crosses come from the byline and arrive low can run a perfectly efficient attack; a side that floats the ball in from deep, again and again, is usually leaving xG on the table no matter how busy the volume column looks. The cross is not banned by the data: it is just asked to justify itself.
Reproduce it
Our analysis script computes every figure on this page from StatsBomb’s event files for the 64 matches of the 2022 World Cup (the match list in StatsBomb Open Data), retrieved June 4, 2026, under the StatsBomb Public Data User Agreement. A cross is a pass StatsBomb flags as one; open play leaves out the corner, free-kick, throw-in, goal-kick and kick-off deliveries themselves; completed means StatsBomb records no failed outcome; a cross led to a shot when it was the pass immediately before it. The totals and both tables are in data/stats/the-overrated-cross.json. No figure here is estimated or hand-entered.
Sources, notes & further reading
- StatsBomb Open Data: the 2022 World Cup event data behind every figure on this page (StatsBomb Public Data User Agreement).
- StatsBomb: research on crossing, cut-backs, and the value of different delivery types.
- The Analyst: explainers on shot quality and chance creation from wide areas.
- FBref: crossing volume, completion and shot-creation data across competitions.
- Understat: shot-level xG you can use to weigh the quality of chances from crosses.
Published by SoccerAnalytics from public data and the sources named in this piece. How this site is made.