For its first half-century the World Cup had no shoot-outs. Drawn knockout matches were settled by replays or, occasionally, the toss of a coin. The penalty shoot-out arrived at the tournament in 1982, and it has since become one of its defining instruments: the mechanism that has decided multiple finals and a long list of quarter- and semi-finals. It looks like chaos and chance. It is, in fact, one of the more predictable corners of the sport, and the numbers behind it are unusually clean.
The World Cup shootout record, kick by kick: does going first win?
Our data files hold nine World Cup shootouts: the five of 2022, which StatsBomb’s open event data records kick by kick, and the four of 2026, which ESPN’s feed records only as a draw after extra time and a team that turns up in the next round. Earlier tournaments are not in any dataset we hold, so nothing before 2022 is counted here; the history further down this page is narrative, not data. Across the 2022 five, the team kicking first won 2, and the first team to miss lost all 5. Neither number means what it seems to.
| Year | Round | Match (after 120 min) | Kicked first | Shootout | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2022 | Round of 16 | Japan 1–1 Croatia | Japan | 1–3 | Croatia |
| 2022 | Round of 16 | Morocco 0–0 Spain | Morocco | 3–0 | Morocco |
| 2022 | Quarter-final | Netherlands 2–2 Argentina | Netherlands | 3–4 | Argentina |
| 2022 | Quarter-final | Croatia 1–1 Brazil | Croatia | 4–2 | Croatia |
| 2022 | Final | Argentina 3–3 France | France | 2–4 | Argentina |
| 2026 | Round of 32 | Germany 1–1 Paraguay | – | – | Paraguay |
| 2026 | Round of 32 | Netherlands 1–1 Morocco | – | – | Morocco |
| 2026 | Round of 32 | Australia 1–1 Egypt | – | – | Egypt |
| 2026 | Round of 16 | Switzerland 0–0 Colombia | – | – | Switzerland |
Going first: 2 wins in 5. That is 40%, and the 95% interval around it (Wilson) runs from 12% to 77%, wide enough to hold a large edge for kicking first, no edge at all, or an edge for kicking second. An exact test against an even split gives p = 1.00. To pin the kick-first win rate within 10 points of one half at 95% confidence takes about 97 shootouts, or more than 19 tournaments at 2022’s five a time. The kicks themselves split the same way: the first-kicking sides scored 13 of 21 (62%), the second-kicking sides 13 of 20 (65%). They failed differently, 7 of the first-kickers’ 8 failures saved against 3 of the second-kickers’ 7, but 41 kicks cannot tell a pattern from noise. The going-first debate below stays open; our record neither confirms nor refutes it.
The first miss: 5 losses in 5. In every 2022 shootout the team that missed first went out (95% interval 57% to 100%). That looks like a law and is mostly arithmetic. If every kick were an independent shot at 2022’s pooled shootout rate (26 of 41, 63%), the first team to miss would still lose 72% of shootouts, because it falls behind and needs the other side to miss too; five losses in five would then happen about 19% of the time. The same model gives the team kicking first exactly a 50% chance, which is the benchmark the 2 of 5 is measured against.
Pressure kicks went in more often, not less. We classed every kick by what it could do. 4 were must-score kicks (a miss ended the shootout against the kicker) and 5 could win it outright. Those 9 went in 7 times (78%): 3 of 4 must-score kicks and 4 of 5 chances to win. The other 32 kicks, taken while nothing could end, went in 19 times (59%). Kicks 1, 2 and 3 converted 6 of 10 each. In 2022 the damage was done early: no shootout reached sudden death, 4 of the 5 ended on a scored kick, and only one (Argentina’s 4–3 over the Netherlands) finished a single goal apart. That runs against the usual story that conversion collapses as the stakes peak, but nine kicks are far too few to overturn it.
| Kicks | Taken | Scored | Rate | Saved | Post / off target |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Side kicking first | 21 | 13 | 62% | 7 | 1 |
| Side kicking second | 20 | 13 | 65% | 3 | 4 |
| Must score (a miss loses) | 4 | 3 | 75% | 0 | 1 |
| Could win (a goal wins) | 5 | 4 | 80% | 0 | 1 |
| Neither | 32 | 19 | 59% | 10 | 3 |
| All kicks | 41 | 26 | 63% | 10 | 5 |
Method and limits. Kick order is StatsBomb’s event order within each match, checked against the full event file of the final. A shootout ends when one side can no longer catch up with the kicks it has left, or, after five rounds each, when the sides have taken the same number and the scores differ; every 2022 shootout ends exactly at its last kick under that rule. Five shootouts is a tiny sample, and 2026 adds nothing to the kick-order question because the feed does not say who kicked first. The listed home side is no stand-in: in 2022 it kicked first in 4 of the 5, not all. How often shootouts happened and what became of 2026’s survivors is in the 2026 shootouts retrospective; where every 2022 penalty went, and the gap between in-game and shootout conversion, is in the shootout discount.
The shoot-out enters the World Cup
The first World Cup shoot-out came at Spain 1982, in the semi-final between West Germany and France: a match still remembered for the drama that preceded the kicks as much as the kicks themselves. From that point on, the shoot-out became the standard tie-breaker for knockout matches level after extra time. Every tournament since has carried the possibility, and most have delivered at least one. The format is fixed and familiar: five kicks each, alternating, sudden death thereafter if still level.
What makes the shoot-out analytically interesting is that it strips the game down to its most repeatable unit. An open-play chance is a one-off; a penalty is nearly the same event every time, which is exactly why the penalty is the most studied shot in football. The shoot-out is that event, stacked: a controlled experiment that happens to decide tournaments.
The conversion rate: about three in four
The single most useful number is the conversion rate, and across penalties in normal play it sits historically around three-quarters, roughly 75%, or about one miss in four. Shoot-out kicks specifically tend to convert a little lower than that. The reason is not the geometry, which is identical; it is the pressure. A shoot-out penalty carries a weight that a first-half spot-kick does not, and that psychological load nudges the success rate down. At the 2022 World Cup the drop came mostly through saves: of the 15 shoot-out kicks that failed, 10 were saved and 5 hit the post or missed the target (the shootout discount has the full census).
That distinction matters. Goalkeepers save most of the shoot-out kicks that fail, but a real share are kicks the keeper never had to touch: a third of 2022’s (5 of 15) hit the woodwork or missed the frame, against one of six failed in-game penalties at the same tournament. Those are failures of the taker, not wins for the goalkeeper. It is one reason post-shot models and goalkeeper-specific metrics treat penalties as a category of their own.
The advantage of going first
One of the more durable findings in the shoot-out literature concerns kicking order. A widely cited body of research argued that the team taking the first penalty in each pair wins more often than the team kicking second, the proposed mechanism being psychological: the side kicking second is repeatedly playing catch-up, taking each kick knowing a miss could end the contest, which is a heavier cognitive burden than kicking with the scoreboard even or ahead.
The honest framing is that this is contested. The original studies reported a sizeable edge for going first; subsequent work with larger and broader samples has found the effect smaller, and some analyses find it weak or inconsistent once you account for everything else. So it is fair to say there is plausibly an advantage to kicking first, that it is the reason captains overwhelmingly choose to go first when they win the toss, and that its true size is genuinely uncertain. What is not in doubt is that teams behave as though it is real: the winner of the coin toss almost always elects to shoot first. Our own record cannot settle it either way: in the five World Cup shootouts we can read kick by kick, the side kicking first won two.
The famous shoot-outs
Three finals anchor the World Cup shoot-out story, and they map neatly onto its statistical themes.
1994, Brazil v Italy. The first, and so far defining, World Cup final decided on penalties. After a goalless match in the Californian heat, the shoot-out ended with Roberto Baggio, the tournament’s outstanding player, sending the decisive kick over the bar. It is the archetypal pressure miss: not a save, but a kick lost to the moment, exactly the failure mode the conversion data predicts under maximum load.
2006, Italy v France. Another final settled from the spot, after a match more remembered for a red card in extra time than for the football. Italy converted their kicks; France did not, with one effort missing the target. A clean, high-conversion shoot-out that nonetheless turned on a single failure. Not every shoot-out is that tight: of the five at the 2022 World Cup, only one (Argentina 4–3 against the Netherlands) finished a single goal apart, and Japan and Spain scored one kick between them.
2022, Argentina v France. A final widely described as one of the greatest, level after extra time and decided on penalties. It closed a tournament in which the shoot-out again did its job: collapsing an unresolvable match into a sequence of single, repeatable kicks. The broader point holds: when a World Cup knockout match cannot be separated in 120 minutes, the tie-breaker is a contest of nerve over a near-identical shot, and the team that loses the fewest kicks wins.
The trainable parts of a shoot-out
This section condenses a separate article first published on 10 June 2026.
High variance is not the same as unpredictable, and a good deal of a shoot-out is coachable. The base rate already favours the taker; preparation protects it.
Order. Who takes which kick is a genuine decision. The conventional logic is to lead with reliable, mentally robust takers to build a cushion and put early pressure on the opponent, and to schedule your best takers within the first five rather than hold them back for a sudden-death slot that may never arrive. How much sequencing matters is debated, and the honest reading is that the effect is real but not enormous; a taker who knows in advance he is first up, and has rehearsed that exact responsibility, carries a different mental load than one handed the ball by surprise.
Keeper homework: the clearest edge. Takers, even elite ones, have tendencies: a preferred side, a favoured height, patterns that show up under pressure. A keeper who has studied them from video and data can weight his dive toward a taker's documented preference. It does not turn a 75%-or-so conversion rate into a coin flip, but shifting even a handful of percentage points across five-plus penalties is the difference between winning and losing a shootout.
Where to aim. The corners, and particularly the upper corners, are the hardest region for a keeper to reach, and placement beats power. Aiming higher and tighter to the post raises the risk of missing the target entirely, so the coaching emphasis is on a repeatable technique that places the ball into a difficult region reliably, grooved and rehearsed under fatigue.
What it means for a forecast. Most tournament models treat a shootout as close to a coin flip between any two teams: a simplifying assumption, not a measured truth. The evidence suggests a refinement: a side with demonstrably better preparation, a strong shot-stopping keeper and a settled cohort of reliable takers should be given a small edge over the coin flip, not parity.
How to think about a shoot-out
The popular description of the shoot-out as a "lottery" is half right and half misleading. It is high-variance: with shoot-out conversion below three in four (63% across 2022’s 41 World Cup kicks) and the loser often just a miss or two behind, the outcome is genuinely close to a coin flip in many matchups, and a better team can and does lose. That is the lottery half, and it is real: the same short-format variance that drives improbable tournament runs and keeps the favourite from winning as often as its quality suggests.
But it is not pure chance. Conversion rates are stable enough to model, the going-first choice is made deliberately for a reason, and shoot-out kicks convert measurably below in-game penalties. A shoot-out is a contest with a known structure and a known base rate, resolved on a thin margin. Calling it random gives up too easily on what the numbers actually tell us, which is that you can say a great deal about shoot-outs in general while remaining almost helpless to predict any single one. That tension is the whole appeal.
Reproduce it
The record section is computed by our analysis script from two sources: the 2022 World Cup event files in StatsBomb’s open-data repository (every shot of the 2022 World Cup; shootout kicks are the penalties in period 5) and /data_layer/wc2026_results.json (ESPN, all 104 matches of 2026, retrieved July 19, 2026; a knockout draw is a shootout, and the winner is the side that plays again). It writes the figures to data/stats/world-cup-penalty-shootout-history-record.json and draws the chart. The coin model is exact, not simulated: it enumerates all 1,024 outcomes of the first five rounds and treats sudden death in closed form. No network, nothing hand-entered.
The data behind this piece
- StatsBomb open data (free public dataset; attribution required): the 2022 World Cup’s 64 matches, read from the 2022 World Cup event files in StatsBomb’s open-data repository; the source of every 2022 kick in the record section.
- ESPN public scoreboard and match-summary feeds (soccer/fifa.world): all 104 matches of 2026, final, retrieved July 19, 2026, bundled as
data_layer/wc2026_results.json. - FIFA: official records of World Cup knockout matches and shoot-out outcomes since 1982.
- RSSSF: detailed match records including extra-time and shoot-out results across the competition’s history.
- StatsBomb: methodology for penalty and shot modelling, including how spot-kicks are valued.
- FBref: penalty conversion data and match records for international football.
Published by SoccerAnalytics from public data and the sources named in this piece. How this site is made.